An interesting article from /. today on defeating Captcha systems. The site referenced in the article lists several Captcha systems that it's program has been able to defeat so far, along with their relative weaknesses.

What may be of interest to ColdFusion developers is a CFX tag, CFX_Captcha has not yet been defeated by the system, and is listed as "A Very Good Captcha" on the PWNtcha site.

It should be noted that the site hasn't been updated in a while, so it is entirely possible that CFX_Captcha has also been defeated. The site author has stated that an update is coming soon.

In the meantime, my personal feeling on Captcha systems is that I don't like them. Although I can appreciate the intent, as a color blind individual, I find many of them difficult to read. I can only imagine the frustration for users with more severe/serious vision issues.

Comments (Comment Moderation is enabled. Your comment will not appear until approved.)
Peter J. Farrell's Gravatar I wonder how Doug Hughes' Alagad Captcha would fair against PWNtcha...

.Peter
# Posted By Peter J. Farrell | 8/24/05 8:56 PM
Scott Stroz's Gravatar Peter - I was thinking the same thing
# Posted By Scott Stroz | 8/24/05 9:34 PM
Raymond Camden's Gravatar I tested Doug's code and liked it, but I too am (genrally) against CAPTCHA. I'm not color blind, but I have a hard time with most of these systems.
# Posted By Raymond Camden | 8/24/05 9:47 PM
Roger Benningfield's Gravatar "I can only imagine the frustration for users with more severe/serious vision issues."

Rob: I'm one of those users, and yeah, CAPTCHAs are an enormous pain. If protecting a site requires major steps, I'd rather see folks use Javascript tokens and so on... I can change browsers or settings in order to access a site, but I can't change my eyes.
# Posted By Roger Benningfield | 8/25/05 12:23 AM
fetish's Gravatar I just wanted to say keep up the good work on your excellent site. <a href="http://alt.swingersadultclubs.com">fetish</a>" target="_blank">http://alt.swingersadultclubs.com">fetish&...;
http://alt.swingersadultclubs.com
# Posted By fetish | 7/11/06 7:44 AM



Copyright 1995-2010 Rob Brooks-Bilson. All rights reserved.
Aura skin for Raymond Camden's BlogCFC inspired by Joe Rinehart & Steven Erat. This blog is running version 5.9.004.